By Beth David, Editor
Fairhaven Town Meeting members voted to ban Flock-type cameras from town at a Special TM on 11/17/26, despite a presentation by the police chief supporting the cameras and a warning by Town Counsel, Heather White, that the vote may not be legal.
Ms. White told TM that the town had a “strong Police Chief” model, so it was doubtful that TM had the authority to ban the cameras. Other TM members also spoke against the article, saying that the Select Board was the appropriate authority to make the change.
The citizen petition was submitted by Joseph Russell. In his presentation, Mr. Russell said the article would not break any contracts, it simply allowed the current contract to expire, and did not allow the police department to renew it.
Flock Cameras, referred to as Automatic License Plate Readers (ALPR) have become controversial because the system is connected to other cameras nationwide. It is not the conventional ALPR that just records the plate number. Flock cameras take a photo of the back of every car that passes through the intersection, and creates a searchable database with identifying information, such as roof racks or dents. Flock calls it a “Vehicle Fingerprint. The cameras can be accessed by law enforcement around the country.
Abuses have been found in multiple municipalities, with police officers tracking former romantic partners, and looking for people without due cause.
The New Bedford Light also ran an article last week saying a Fairhaven Police Officer used the vague term “welfare check” more than 750 times.
Fairhaven Police Chief Daniel Dorgan said the officer did not want to flag that he was looking for drug dealers because the auditing information on the cameras can be obtained by the public, and therefore, the subject.
Which, it seems, only proved the point of skeptics, that the information could get into the wrong hands.
Mr. Russell told TM that the camera records everyone, innocent or not.
“Rights aren’t only for people with something to hide,” said Mr. Russell.
He noted that the police chief told the Select Board that Fairhaven shares information with about 260 other cities and towns from Fairhaven to Florida. He noted that the town does not share with the federal government…now.
“But a setting is not a wall,” said Mr. Russell. “Every protection on this network is a checkbox in a software menu, and checkboxes get changed.”
He said conventional cameras are still allowed, and cameras on homes are allowed.
“What ends is recording everybody, all the time, in order to find somebody, someday,” he said.
More than 40 municipalities in the state have blocked the use of Flock cameras.
Chief Dorgan made his case in favor of the cameras, showing cases that were solved because of the unique capabilities of the Flocks.
He also highlighted the many safeguards, and stressed that not all officers can access the system. They need training, he said.
Chief Dorgan said the photo does not see where a car turns, it only sees the car’s rear. The data are deleted in seven days, and the town does not share with federal agencies.
Several people spoke, with at mix of those against the cameras and those for it.
Jim Anderson said it was “nonsense to say that AI cannot access the system.
Former police chief Gary Souza supported the officer who had been the subject of the NB Light article. He asked if the officer was part of the drug task force and Chief Dorgan confirmed it.
The Chief said the searches were for law enforcement purposes and the officer had concern for the integrity of the investigations.
TM member Ilga said that unless the town had its own servers, an actual hard drive in its possession, then they do not own the date.
Anne Soares said the town has no idea how the information is being used.
TM member Cameron Durant said TM was the wrong place to propose the ban. He said the authority was with the Select Board.
“We’re on the wrong side of history with this right now,” said Kevin Grant. “But we can change that tonight.”
Wayne Hayward said he was torn by the article. In any case, he said, “The horse if out of the barn,” as far as protecting personal data is concerned.
In the end, the vote looked close enough to require a count. Town Moderator, Mark Sylvia, clarified that a “yes” vote would end the use of the cameras and a “no” vote would leave things as they are.
The vote was 92 yes, and 77 no.
The measure will now go to the Attorney General’s Office, which will decide if it can be legally implemented.
Town Meeting members also approved a series of bylaws changes recommended by the Special Bylaw Review Committee which reviewed bylaws to bring them into conformity with the newly adopted Town Charter.
An article calling for reassignment of a Conservation Restriction from the Buzzards Bay Coalition to the Conservation Commission on Weeden Road was passed over at the request of the ConCom chairperson.
In article 4, TM also voted to transfer $253,256 from the West Island Treatment Plant Capital Improvements from 2020, to the Sewer Nitrogen Plant Article from 2022. Public Works Superintendent, Vinnie Furtado, said the WITP improvements came in under budget. The upgrade of the plant on Arsene Street is ongoing.
He noted that the Board of Public Works saved the town about $30 million by jumping through hoops to get grants and securing a zero interest loan from the state for $50 million in borrowing for the project.
At the very end of the meeting, TM member Cindy Johnson made it a point to thank the BPW and Mr. Furtado for going through the hoops, eliciting lots of clapping.
In other business, TM members voted in favor all other articles:
• Article 1 to appropriate $172,114.21 in insurance proceeds to fix water damage from a broken pipe at East Fairhaven School during the February 2026 blizzard.
• Articles 2, to fund the Dispatch Union Agreement.
• Article 3, to allow the BPW to lease space on and around the water tower on Sconticut Neck Road for a communications antenna
• Article 5: transfer $30,348 in unexpended wages for the FY27 Accounting Department budget to used for succession planning and the costs of hiring a new town accountant.
• Article 7: Establish/readopt OPEB Trust.
•••
Click here to download the 11/19/26 issue: 11-19-26 FhvnVetsParade
Support local journalism, donate to the Neighb News with PayPal



